RDC delays rescission decision on Shonto Chapter’s business site leasing delegation

By Robert Bettis
Navajo Times

KAYENTA

Tensions flared at Tuesday’s public hearing as the Resource and Development Committee members decided whether to revoke Shonto Chapter’s authority to manage business site leases, a power granted 17 years ago.

Robert Bettis | Navajo Times
Shonto Vice President Robert Black Jr. addresses the Resources and Development Committee members, drawing on his 13 years of experience as both a chapter manager and a business officer to explain Shonto’s leasing challenges.

After hours of testimony, the RDC postponed its decision until April 30, citing missing documentation and unresolved questions about accountability.

The dispute centers on the completed but unopened Shonto Hotel, a $20 million project that can’t open yet because of a lack of completed paperwork. Charlene Begay Platero of the Division of Economic Development testified that Shonto’s failure to finalize a lease with operator Medallion Hospitality violates multiple regulations.

Robert Bettis | Navajo Times
Shonto Chapter President Marsha Greyeyes testifies before the Navajo Nation Resources and Development Committee on April 9, defending the chapter’s 17-year leasing authority amid DED’s revocation efforts.

“We completed our task, and the facility is ready to open,” Platero told the committee, “But there is no lease for the lessee to operate.

“The Nation and the community are missing out on sales tax, hotel occupancy tax, and income for 30 Navajo workers.”

To read the full article, please see the April 17, 2025, edition of the Navajo Times.

Get instant access to this story by purchasing one of our many e-edition subscriptions here at our Navajo Times Store.