Letters | Flood recovery
Flood recovery
Editor,
(This is to) everyone across the tribal nations and four states recovering from the devastating floods last week, our thoughts and hearts are with you as you navigate this crisis.
We are pausing our outreach for the next few weeks. We’ll be back in touch when the time is more appropriate with new information about our initiative, as well as additional low-cost, ecologically-restorative strategies that can help the Four Corners region gently recover from drought and better manage extreme weather, quickly and affordably.
With sympathy and deepest concerns, sending our best.
Chris Searles
Founder/director
BioIntegrity Partnerships
Austin, Texas
Water priorities
Editor,
I wish to share a few thoughts with your readers.
First, general election is upon us again to elect leaders of the Navajo Nation for the next four years. And there are so many issues that remain unresolved.
The voters took care of the president during the primary election, and I fully agree with their decision. In less than two weeks a new president and vice president will be elected. They will for the next few weeks thereafter build a new administration to resolve many of those unsolved issues. I with them the very best.
One and foremost in my mind is water. We are taught by our parents and grandparents that water is life. This statement is true. We can’t survive without water. We all understand that and we all agree.
What I don’t understand is why do our leaders continue to invite and grant leases to these Bilagáana industries for 50 years and now there is one underway for 110 years. Every industry now on the reservation needs water to operate their businesses, lots of water, our water.
Not too long ago, the Resources and Development Committee reported there are over 100 developers waiting outside the reservation wanting and asking for a lease to extract minerals. This is happening because President Nygren in early April 2025 went to the White House and met with Mr. Yellowhair and thanked him for the numerous executive orders he issued for energy development on public lands, including all of the Navajo land.
We need leaders in both the Executive and Legislative Branch to protect our precious resources and protect the people, not the Bilagáana. Every one of these Bilagáana are millionaires or billionaires.
Water rights. When asked, the Executive and Legislative branches will say there are two bills pending in Congress to give water rights to the Navajo, Hopi and the Paiutes. That’s true but what they don’t tell you is these bills will likely die at the end of this year.
The other issue they don’t talk much about is in August of this year the Department of Interior, under Mr. Yellowhair, issued a rule on the use of Colorado River, which went into effect early this month (October) directing Arizona, California, and Nevada to cut back on the use of the river by 31 percent. This will be in effect for the next two years, probably 2028/2029.
The hope was during this time the states would negotiate the use of the river. Instead Nevada already sued the federal government, and this will take many years to resolve, probably will end up in the Supreme Court. As a result of this rule, I don’t believe there will be a bill introduced in Congress any time soon.
The water we are entitled to from the river is getting smaller. The administration and the Legislative Branch got rid of all the water rights lawyers. The nation has only one water rights lawyer. This is another major reason why we need a new administration.
Unfinished ARPA projects. The Navajo Nation received over $2 billion dollars a few years ago to address the issue of Covid-19 by providing water to every home. According to the report by the controller, there are tens of millions of dollars unspent and $30 million or so lost. The deadline for spending this money is at the end of this year. I’m just so afraid that the U.S. Treasury Department will ask the nation to repay millions of dollars, including those that are lost. Many of the water lines installed are dry, no water. Bathroom additions were provided, most without water lines, no tanks, and no water.
The administration and the Council spend months (years) discussing how to spend the money. All this happened under two administrations, still not done. Water projects left unfinished and not completed. Will it be completed and families can have their water? I and hundreds of families are left with uncertainty.
Late September, the Council, rather than finding a way to finish the ARPA projects, decided instead to provide hardship assistance to the elderly with $250. I would rather have the water. It would last for years. Most of the $250 will end up in Gallup, Flagstaff, Page, and Farmington to support their businesses and the cities’ sales tax revenues. Very, very little will stay on the reservation. The ARPA-related failures are other reasons why we need a new administration.
Recently, a delegate, together with the speaker, introduced legislation to place on the coming election ballot a question for the voters whether to raise the salaries of Council delegates from $25,000 to $70,000 dollars. This is huge. I often hear the words “transparency,” “accountability,” and “no money” from our leaders. The legislation appears to have forgotten those words.
The Council recently approved a new redistricting. Each delegate represents approximately 6,688 in population. Compare this to Arizona state legislators, they each represent approximately 237,000 population with a salary of $24,000 per year. New Mexico and Utah legislators have no salary. They get only expenses for their meetings. I’m sure they represent over 200,000 population in their district.
The Navajo Nation has numerous corporations, enterprises, commercial and hospitalities, energy corporations and utilities each have a board of directors, and they all pay up to $500 per meeting plus expenses. Most of these meetings are once a month. Every delegate sits on these boards, some on more than one. All of these are not reported and kept from the people.
The total cost of the raise for the 24 delegates is $1,680,000 per year. For four years it’s $6,720,000. No other legislators anywhere have a salary that large. This is a 180 percent increase in salary, this is outrageous. Navajo Nation normally gives a 2 or 3 percent increase to their employees.
Our leaders have forgotten the Diné Fundamental Laws. Each legislation and each decision made were done so as if the fundamental law does not exist. Our new leadership must revisit this law and honor it completely. We truly need a new administration. A new administration is not someone to go from one side of the street to another side and then call themselves a new administration. That wouldn’t work.
With all the above and so much more, I endorse the Jones/Ellison ticket. May the Great Spirits guide and be with all of us.
Percy Deal
Big Mountain, Ariz.
Pollution allegations
Editor,
(This is to the) New Mexico Environment Department, Bureau of Reclamation and the New Mexico Office of the State Engineer:
I want to ask you: do you think that you know what you are doing? A family owns 1.7 miles of the Shumway Arroyo, and you already knew that we owned it. And you have knowingly allowed the Public Services Company of New Mexico to pollute the Shumway Arroyo for the last 50 years. Under whose authority did you pollute this property? I want to see it in writing.
You have allowed them to poison the children, the parents and the livestock of that family, as well as who knows how many other families downstream and how much livestock also.
Then you have allowed the sale of the freshwater reservoir, also known as “Frank Chee Willeto Reservoir” to the Bureau of Reclamation for $8 million. The water that filled the Frank Chee Willeto Reservoir is polluted and there is a check for $74,258.87 that is a settlement for the deaths of livestock that were drinking the water from the many leaks along the reservoir supply pipeline. The chemicals that they had used were used to extend the lifespan of the pipeline.
Now you have a congressperson bragging about getting the $800 million funding for the Gallup-Navajo water supply pipeline. Yet we are sending the test results of the water tested flowing along the bedrock at the “Cindy Hertado PNM SJGS” to the Bureau of Reclamation. Yet politics will not allow them to read the findings.
We are dealing with facts, and everyone is refusing to read or understand the results. The innocent farmer is going to have to spend at least $100,000 to try to restore his farm, and he might not get it accomplished. And he also falls under the Americans with Disabilities Act. His property has 197,000,000 gallons of spring water flowing from his property along the Shumway Arroyo, now they are trying to deprive him of that.
There was a man from the Bureau of Reclamation that called him. He told him that the water from the “Frank Chee Willetto Reservoir” was cleaner than the water from the San Juan River, this is a lie. Besides, he told me that the water was not flowing against the bedrock going into the Shumway Arroyo, which is also a lie.
If you had done your due diligence, you would not have wasted your money with PNM. The government employees need to be held accountable rather than laugh about what you had forced upon others and thought you got away with.
The lies and corruption need to stop. There are innocent people who believe that their lives and futures are not at stake, even though it is in peril.
R.G. Hunt III
Waterflow, N.M.
Polling access
Editor,
(This is to) Navajo Nation leaders, chapters, division directors and employees:
On behalf of the Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission, we thank Navajo Nation employees, local leaders, county officials, and all others preparing Navajo citizens for the 2026 General Election. The commission has supported education on voting rights, election deadlines, and ballot initiatives in Arizona, New Mexico, and Utah.
Many chapter houses will serve as polling places for elections administered by the Navajo Nation Election Administration and the county officials. Shared facilities are often necessary because some communities lack suitable buildings for separate tribal and state elections. The commission support shared polling place locations when they provide safe, convenient access. Limited space must never prevent an eligible voter from casting both ballots.
Reports from the 2026 Primary Election show that some communities need stronger planning and collaboration before the General Election. We urge chapter administrations, the Election Administration, tribal departments and county officials to continue collaborating. Plans for access, staffing, signs, voter flow, and opening times must be completed and shared in advance.
Closing Navajo Nation offices on Election Day must not delay access to chapter houses or other tribal polling places. State and tribal law requires polls to open at specific times. Chapter administration and local leaders must ensure that every approved facility is unlocked, ready and accessible before voting begins.
We ask every Navajo Nation director, employee, chapter official and administrator, and county partner to do their part. This requires respect, communication and a shared commitment to our people. The right to vote is a basic human right. No Navajo voter should lose that right because offices are closed, facilities are unavailable, or agencies did not coordinate. By working together, we can remove barriers and ensure that every eligible Navajo citizen can vote in both tribal and state elections. We urge your leadership and immediate support in making the 2026 General Election accessible, orderly, and successful in every Navajo community. Thank you for your leadership and commitment.
Austin Yazzie
Executive director
Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission
St. Michaels, Ariz.
Uranium oversight
Editor,
When the New Mexico Environment Department announced a new Community Impact Assessment process for a proposed uranium mining project near Churchrock, it introduced an opportunity for communities to raise concerns before the formal groundwater discharge permit comment period.
That’s a positive step. But for the process to be meaningful, NMED must make sure community members can participate in this new process and that their concerns are accurately represented and considered.
The proposed Churchrock-Crownpoint in-situ recovery project by Laramide Resources and its subsidiary, NuFuels, includes uranium mining sites near both communities under a single federal license. The project would use in-situ leach mining, also referred to by industry as in-situ recovery or ISR, to extract uranium from underground formations. Nearby tribal communities have experienced generations of uranium development and continue to live with the impacts of legacy mine and mill waste.
The 1979 Church Rock uranium mill tailings spill – the largest accidental release of radioactive material in U.S. history – sent radioactive waste into the Puerco River and remains a stark example of the lasting consequences of uranium mining in this region.
The CIA process gives community members an opportunity to raise concerns about cumulative impacts, including water quality, health, transportation, cultural resources and the disproportionate burdens communities continue to experience from past mining.
Importantly, those concerns can become part of the official record before NMED makes a decision on the groundwater discharge permit.
NMED has the authority to approve, deny, or require changes to the permit. The department has told New Mexico Mining Watch that comments submitted through the CIA process will be considered in its review of the Churchrock-Crownpoint application.
That’s why this additional opportunity for public input matters. But we have serious concerns about how the process is being carried out.
First, the assessment should be prepared independently. Under the current approach, NuFuels would prepare the CIA for its own proposed project. Given the area’s history of uranium contamination and ongoing cleanup needs, communities have good reason to question whether the company can provide a complete and accurate account of cumulative impacts.
NMED should require a qualified, independent third party to prepare the assessment, at the company’s expense. The department should also ensure that community concerns are documented accurately and considered in its permit decision.
Second, participation needs to be accessible. Community members should know about the process before it begins, understand what they’re being asked to comment on, and have meaningful opportunities to participate. That means public notices that reach affected communities, information available in the Navajo language, and options to provide comments verbally rather than only in writing.
The extension of the CIA comment deadline to Nov. 5 at the request of NMMW on behalf of communities provides additional time, but it doesn’t resolve the need for better communication and accessibility.
Finally, NMED must show how community input influences its decisions. Collecting comments isn’t enough. The department should explain how concerns about cumulative impacts are evaluated, whether they lead to additional protections or changes to the project, and how they factor into the final permit decision.
We encourage NMED to continue using the CIA process to evaluate community concerns on future mining proposals, but it is vital that they create systems where communities can participate meaningfully, and where community input is accurately compiled and considered in agency decision-making.
We encourage residents to submit comments on the Churchrock-Crownpoint CIA by Nov. 5. It is important that there is as much community participation as possible. You don’t need technical expertise to participate. Your knowledge of the land, water, community health, and the consequence of past mining is essential and important.
For more information and help submitting comments, visit NMMW on Facebook to find our public comment toolkit.
Communities deserve more than an opportunity to be heard. They deserve a process that takes what they say seriously.
Teracita Keyanna
Red Water Pond Road Community Association
Churchrock, N.M.
Eric Jantz
New Mexico Environmental Law Center
Albuquerque, N.M.
Readers can support Navajo Times journalism with an e-Edition subscription, available through our Navajo Times Store.
Highway 264,
I-40, WB @ Winslow